Ours are a tie between a young John Slatterly (giving James Dean a serious run for his money) and the boyish grin of a young Andrew McCarthy. Ok maybe that one's just me. Honorable mentions: Pratt, Lowe and Ruffalo.
Skinny Pratt, the original.
Outsiders-era Matt Dillon before his face got all big and weird.
80s Gere lean.
"OK, so he's kind of a Baldwin" - Cher Horowitz
This era Jagger is sexy and he knows it.
Classic all-American boy Robert Redford.
Rob Lowe was doing the wear yourself on a t-shirt thing long before the whole Gosling-Bieber meme.
Brooklyn-Pacino, before Brooklyn was cool.
Paul Newman is OK we guess, if you're into that kind of thing.
Baby Elvis was a BABE.
And finally, John Slatterly and Andrew McCarthy. Who did we miss??